I like both, but I really prefer Jill. I like her eyes because I looove purple, her clothes are nice, and.. well, I'm kind of sick of looking at Claire's sprite. Having played as her in MFoMT, I'd rather get a breath of fresh air and play as someone different. Plus, the overalls bore me because of Jack, and they sorta make her look like a country bumpkin. It makes sense considering she is a farmer, but still. xD I do prefer her loose, simple hair to Jill's double ponytail thing, but I prefer being a brunette. So.. yeah, I likes me some Jill. xD
..I don't have Cute (YET! >8D) so I can't really base my opinions on in-game appearance or anything.. I have yet to suffer the agony of Jill's 8DDDD face. </3
I really like both but I look more like Claire, I think. But my blond is a bit darker blond, not super light :/ so I donno. I played as Jill though cuz I just played MFoMT a bunch, and even when I started out in MFoMT her sprited bugged me, so...
The guy in her sig is will, a new bachelor in shining sun and friends, im marrying him when it comes out, im not getting ioh becuase he is only in shining friends and i wanted to narry him, soooo.
i personally tought claire looked a bit too barbie-ish for my tastes, so i went with jill. XD she looks cuter imo..and also, i have chocolate brown hair. :D and i like her gloves, hehe.
I usually prefer Jill. I don't like blonde hair too much. And I hate overalls. Jill's clothes are far more stylish, in my opinion. I also love Jill's hair color and her ponytail.
I wish Jill wore her hair down. I usually have a file with both. For example, on Jill's file she's marrying Marlin. On Claire's file she's marrying Rock...hahaha! XD