Year One Cooking Festival

**Posts:** 316

I've been replaying day one of the cooking festival over and over again. I have read in multiple places that you can win with 3.5 stars, and the best entree dish I can make is a 3.5 star fish stew. I lose to Joan every time. I'm willing to keep playing it if there really is a chance, but I'm getting fed up fast. Has any here ever actually *won* with a 3.5 star dish? I just want to be absolutely sure that it's even possible.

Pokefarm · **Posts:** 1892

I've never won with a 3.5 star dish, even with resetting.

The lowest I've won with would be a 4 star dish.

**Posted:** May 21, 2012 7:26 am

what recipes normally win a cooking festival?

**Posted:** May 21, 2012 2:33 pm

I make an omelet for day 1 and pudding for day 2. It's simple but it wins me a pink diamond.

**Posts:** 1765

Aster wrote:

I make an omelet for day 1 and pudding for day 2. It's simple but it wins me a pink diamond.

This. These are simple, but it can help because of the rate of things you use in it.

I've won with a 4 star. 5 was in year 2, but you could probably get by with a 4.

**Posts:** 1093

I agree with what everyone said.
It would be easier if you enter with a 4 star dish.

**Posts:** 254

Authors_Wrath wrote:

I've been replaying day one of the cooking festival over and over again. I have read in multiple places that you can win with 3.5 stars, and the best entree dish I can make is a 3.5 star fish stew. I lose to Joan every time. I'm willing to keep playing it if there really is a chance, but I'm getting fed up fast. Has any here ever actually *won* with a 3.5 star dish? I just want to be absolutely sure that it's even possible.

Not sure about 3.5, only 4.0

**Posts:** 230

i never thought about entering with a 3-star dish, not even a 4.
Only because i always thought about winning. Always.

Always.

Always.

Ushi No Tane - Harvest Moon

Year One Cooking Festival