Jack's Past Girl?

**Posts:** 336

i have always wondered who is the girl that became friends with Jack in the past... many players say that it doesn't matters, that we can choose the girl. but, i'd like to know who's the true one! you may not know the answer, so at least vote for the bachelorette you think it's the girl from the past, and why you chose her!

:-|

**Posts:** 1741

I can easily see it being anyone, but I guess the Goddess? She already knows you and your name at the beginning of the game and there's no clear reason why.(besides the fact that she's a goddess.)

**Posts:** 336

GenesisLove wrote:

besides the fact that she's a goddess.

this only fact makes it almost impossible. and i'm half-sure she only knows your name because she's a goddess, and normally deities knows of everything?

**Posts:** 1741

Isn't she only a very minor « Harvest Goddess »? I mean, all she's supposed to do is bless the land for a good harvest or something. It's not like she can read minds.

**Posts:** 336

oh yeah, good point. i should've typed: she knows the villagers names.

**Posts:** 19911

in BTN, it's canon that it's whichever girl you marry, so i'm going with that for this game, too.

**Posts:** 3788

I remember a topic like this a while ago and someone said the girl was Aja, Duke and Manna's daughter.

**Posts:** 2195

HMM wrote:

I remember a topic like this a while ago and someone said the girl was Aja, Duke and Manna's daughter.

That would have been awesome. I wish there was a cutscene where she comes back. I really wanna see what she looks like

**Posts:** 1055

spicy_sugar wrote:

That would have been awesome. I wish there was a cutscene where she comes back. I really wanna see what she looks like

Agreed! I'd love to see Aja return, even if only for a short while. I always imagined her to look very casual, but elegant, with long black hair let loose.

**Posts:** 5627

I think in BTN when you married a girl they confessed to being the girl in the past (like the boys confess to being the one who saves you in BTN For Girl) but it's not mentioned in FoMT.

I kinda like to think it's the Goddess :3 Gives her a little more depth.

**Posts:** 2625

suzy parsley wrote:

i have always wondered who is the girl that became friends with Jack in the past... many players say that it doesn't matters, that we can choose the girl. but, i'd like to know who's the true one! you may not know the answer, so at least vote for the bachelorette you think it's the girl from the past, and why you chose her!

:-|

IIRC, in my BTN playthrough, the girl you marry will the the girl from your past. The event will take place in about year 3 and 5? Your wife will say that she was the girl from before.

I see Nina mentioning it now...just want to add in more details.

Aja being the past girl would be so cool. :'D

**Posts:** 19911

i think she says so at evaluation? but it's been about 10 years since i've actually beaten BTN, so my memory might be a little fuzzy!

wait... according to youtube videos of the endings, after you go talk to all the villagers, your wife will bring you somewhere to talk and she will tell you that she is the girl. now i remember. :D

**Posts:** 1741

^Are you sure? That sounds suspiciously similar to HM 64.

**Posts:** 19911

there was no "past girl" in 64.

at the 64 evaluation, your dad goes around and talks to the villagers (gourmet, shipper, midwife, fisherman, etc.) that talk about how well you did in each category (recipes, shipping, girls, fishing, etc.), then invites all your friends to the farm for a party. after they all leave, your wife brings you over to your deck (if you have one, if not, then the place where the deck should be) and asks if you knew what your grandfather's last words meant, to which you can answer yes or no, which has no bearing on the rest of the game.

in BTN, thomas comes to your farm, tells you how well you did, then brings you to the square, where all the villagers praise you in a big party, then your wife brings you to the top of the mountain and tells you that she was the girl from long ago.

i've beaten 64 a -lot-, and i just looked up the BTN ending on youtube to refresh my memory. look it up if you still think i'm thinking of 64's evaluation~

**Posted:** Sep 11, 2011 11:49 am

Mmm...The girl may not have a specific identity, but with that dress and hair I always thought she looked quite a bit like Ellie.

Ushi No Tane - Harvest Moon

Jack's Past Girl?