Page 1 of 2

Anyone else dislike how Marvelous keeps using the 64 goddess

Posted: Sep 16, 2011 10:31 am
by Guest
They've used her many times. Sometimes it makes sense, like for DS and Cute (the AWL goddess is implied to be the FOMT one too). But at other times you can just tell they don't want to make up a new goddess.

She honestly has to be my least favorite goddess, both in terms of personality and design.

Re: Anyone else dislike how Marvelous keeps using the 64 « Harvest Goddess »

Posted: Sep 16, 2011 10:41 am
by Shizuru
I agree with you; they need a new Goddess. Preferably a nice one.

Re: Anyone else dislike how Marvelous keeps using the 64 « Harvest Goddess »

Posted: Sep 16, 2011 11:28 am
by Googaboga
Well in MM/HoLV and ToT/AP they have a different Goddess.

The ToT/AP one is very nice. The MM one is nice but in HoLV she isn't as nice :/.

I guess it is just tradition to use that Goddess in the DS games. They always have. Oh well maybe when they make a 3DS HM game they'll shake it up and use a different Goddess.

Re: Anyone else dislike how Marvelous keeps using the 64 « Harvest Goddess »

Posted: Sep 16, 2011 11:33 am
by Chaos_44
I mean, I did get sick of her eventually. But I liked that she progressed in later games. In 64 she was just whatever, then she had more of a personality in the MT games, then she added her TADAAHHH catchphrase. I'm kinda sick of her now, though.

Re: Anyone else dislike how Marvelous keeps using the 64 « Harvest Goddess »

Posted: Sep 16, 2011 4:01 pm
by Dragoonwing
Save the Homelands had the best goddess bar none. Cute and she had attitude... though whenever she was angry she would give a sinister smile...

Re: Anyone else dislike how Marvelous keeps using the 64 « Harvest Goddess »

Posted: Sep 16, 2011 5:31 pm
by Guest
My favorite is the Magical Melody one honestly.

Re: Anyone else dislike how Marvelous keeps using the 64 « Harvest Goddess »

Posted: Sep 16, 2011 6:21 pm
by pshycho
I want to see what they come up with if they decide to make a brand new one. I think it'd be interesting. But the MM HG is my favorite. I don't mind the AP one either though...

Actually, I don't really care. Unless I have to save her, I don't care that much about the HG...
I'm a horrible person

Re: Anyone else dislike how Marvelous keeps using the 64 « Harvest Goddess »

Posted: Sep 16, 2011 6:39 pm
by lemo_the_lemon
Yeah, she's my least favorite Goddess.

My favorite being HoLV because hhrhrrrnnngggg she's so beautiful and cute~

Re: Anyone else dislike how Marvelous keeps using the 64 « Harvest Goddess »

Posted: Sep 16, 2011 8:02 pm
by Kemine
Honestly I never really thought it about it. XD I would say something about like, thinking how it'd be nice to just scrap out the entire goddess thing because for me, they're all just the same. My dad used to call her the Harvest Fairy, so I've been calling her that ever since I heard him do so when I was like...8. XD

I dunno, for the most part don't you just throw in something like a flower or a strawberry and out she comes? It never bothered me too much, haha.

Re: Anyone else dislike how Marvelous keeps using the 64 « Harvest Goddess »

Posted: Sep 17, 2011 3:30 am
by kaitouX
I think it's about time they've moved on to another Goddess. I liked the way she was in M/FoMT, but with how they've changed her in DS/Cute and later games, I couldn't stand her anymore.

While it would be nice if we got a new Goddess, I wouldn't mind seeing the older ones, either - the AP Goddess, whose design I utterly adored - she looked so magical and dignified - or the HoLV one.

Re: Anyone else dislike how Marvelous keeps using the 64 « Harvest Goddess »

Posted: Sep 17, 2011 7:10 am
by garnet_goodie
The "Let's Harvest Moon" Goddess is so cute.

Image

But the similarity in design to the more iconic 64-onwards Goddess leads me to believe she could possibly be the same character but say, a "younger" version of her. Not canon-confirmed from far as I know of just how I perceived it.

Image

(Like if all the Harvest Moon games are in fact within the same universe somehow I always accepted that the different Goddesses were just "sisters" of sorts.)

Re: Anyone else dislike how Marvelous keeps using the 64 « Harvest Goddess »

Posted: Sep 17, 2011 10:13 am
by kaitouX
Oooh, I didn't know of that Goddess! She's so beautiful. :) But who are the other characters? They remind me of the personifications of Winter and Autumn, respectively.

Re: Anyone else dislike how Marvelous keeps using the 64 « Harvest Goddess »

Posted: Sep 17, 2011 10:27 am
by Ranger
My favorite goddess would have to be ToT/AP's one. MM was great too, though. Couldn't stand HoLV's, although she was very pretty.

Re: Anyone else dislike how Marvelous keeps using the 64 « H

Posted: Sep 17, 2011 11:11 am
by garnet_goodie
kaitouX wrote:Oooh, I didn't know of that Goddess! She's so beautiful. :) But who are the other characters? They remind me of the personifications of Winter and Autumn, respectively.
Not quite sure since I've been looking around trying to figure that out myself but not getting a lot (though the girl seems more Summery considering her implied fire powers; I can imagine the Goddess being Spring)

I want to get around to trying to play this game but I fail so hard with things like this with only just a translation guide on hand (I have a hard time having a smooth gameplay experience/sob dating sims) - but I believe several Ushians and just general Harvest Moooers have been playing and it seems to very visual-based and simple anyway and have had no complaints (It's "Farmville-esque") soooo ~

Re: Anyone else dislike how Marvelous keeps using the 64 « Harvest Goddess »

Posted: Sep 17, 2011 11:24 am
by Googaboga
I know the guy. His name is Cyan He runs a special place that I think trades animals for better breeds or something.

A long time ago I made a topic about that game asking if there were other characters besides the HG and HS. The girl wasn't out yet so I don't know who she is.