The ToTT Theory Topic.

sararuby · Post Posted: Dec 05, 2011 4:39 pm

CyanideConfections wrote:Ayame X Hayate would solve everything...

and WHAT?!
i can imagine any of the other bachelors being mistaken as girls, but KANA? he's the manliest one in the game in my opinion
much manlier than a florist
/shot by Cam fans

Well he reminds me of a female friend I had once and now I keep seeing him as a girl. Weird huh?

Post Posted: Dec 05, 2011 4:42 pm

sararuby wrote:
CyanideConfections wrote:Ayame X Hayate would solve everything...

and WHAT?!
i can imagine any of the other bachelors being mistaken as girls, but KANA? he's the manliest one in the game in my opinion
much manlier than a florist
/shot by Cam fans
Well he reminds me of a female friend I had once and now I keep seeing him as a girl. Weird huh?

yep so very weird well back to theorys bc thts what this place is for so lets get more on iro and kana

vie · Post Posted: Dec 05, 2011 4:43 pm

May be because he has long hair.. *i know that weird reason,, ~.~

Off topic, at old school fan club, someone just said that he confused Cliff as a girl when kid and played hm64. Just because he have tailed long hair.

back to topic. love hiroxkana theory. I heard when you married Kana, he will asked to say goodbye to Hiro when MC moved from konohana to bluebell. what's more suspicious.. xD

Post Posted: Dec 05, 2011 4:45 pm

vie wrote:May be because he has long hair.. *i know that weird reason,, ~.~

Off topic, at old school fan club, someone just said that he confused Cliff as a girl when kid and played hm64. Just because he have tailed long hair.

back to topic. love hiroxkana theory. I heard when you married Kana, he will asked to say goodbye to Hiro when MC moved from konohana to bluebell. what's more suspicious.. xD

NO CLIFF IS HAWT + HE REMINDS ME OF gohan from DBZ NOT DBZK

CyanideConfections · Post Posted: Dec 05, 2011 5:13 pm

hmmm, long hair does seem girlish to some, so i guess i could understand it, but i know many guys irl with long hair and many girls with very short hair
and i guess that makes sense if you new someone irl similar to Kana so that Kana reminds you of her.
at first i couldn't tell if Mikhail was a girl or a boy, but only because all of his faces except for his normal one seemed feminine to me. once i saw him in game he looked more like a boy.
and i thought that Hiro looked about 4 in online pics, but he looks like an 18 year old in my game

Jada · Post Posted: Dec 05, 2011 5:15 pm

I showed a friend the choices of bachelors. He's never encountered Harvest Moon, so he had no context to place them in and he thought they were all very feminine. Of course, HM has always been very cutesy, so in the frame of the game, Kana seems pretty manly.

CyanideConfections · Post Posted: Dec 05, 2011 5:19 pm

that is very true. i'd rather have feminine males to choose from though than old men (like in HMDS:Cute)
they also always make the girls look young

RavenWing · Post Posted: Dec 05, 2011 5:28 pm

Huh. To me, Cam doesn't look like a girl, he just looks like a pretty boy. The weird thing is, Kana reminds me of this girl I knew. So I crossed him out >_<
Theory, huh? I just second the strange Ayame x Hiro relationship theory. Something's not quiet right.

Mizukithepanda · Post Posted: Dec 05, 2011 5:37 pm

vie wrote:May be because he has long hair.. *i know that weird reason,, ~.~

Off topic, at old school fan club, someone just said that he confused Cliff as a girl when kid and played hm64. Just because he have tailed long hair.

For the record, I was about nine or ten. (The game had just come out too, so there wasn't much on the internet for it either.) Due to school rules, guys didn't have long hair and HM64's graphics obscured gender well enough that it wasn't immediately obvious that Cliff was male. And, as I was always rather the loner tomboy (still am), the idea of a girl who was similar was intriguing.

Regardless.... on the theory subject....

Spoiler:

Post Posted: Dec 05, 2011 6:00 pm

What would happen if renia and cam got together but....someone got jeulous

Spoiler:

TADA!!!

Cherry Blossom · Post Posted: Dec 05, 2011 6:03 pm

Mizukithepanda wrote:Regardless.... on the theory subject....
Spoiler:
The MC of Twin Villages is totally Cliff and Ann's offspring. No doubt.

True, true.
They do look alike.
But which one? :O

Mizukithepanda · Post Posted: Dec 05, 2011 6:05 pm

Cherry Blossom wrote:
Mizukithepanda wrote:Regardless.... on the theory subject....
Spoiler:
The MC of Twin Villages is totally Cliff and Ann's offspring. No doubt.
True, true.
They do look alike.
But which one? :O

My immediate thought was the male MC, but honestly, I think both of them look like they'd be related to those two.

Kurai27 · Post Posted: Dec 05, 2011 6:31 pm

Farmy wrote:Ash and Cheryl? Totally doing it.

Ok, so I know this is a little off topic from what's being said now, but this theory kinda got blown off. But, it's actually kinda plausible considering that the Japanese like some of the stranger fetishes/complexes. This one included. I mean, has anyone ever read or watched Angel Sanctuary by Kaori Yuki? Don't get me wrong, she's awesome and her manga Godchild is amazing too, it even has some instances of sibling love in it. And I bet most of us on here have heard of Ouran Host Club, granted the Hitachiin twins aren't really together but they make themselves out to be for the girls. And not only is it popular in Japan but it is here as well, granted it isn't always real siblings but step or half or adoption or something similar. I mean has anyone been on FF.N lately? Practically any popular series with a set of siblings has at least one story with them paired together, I can't count how many times I have seen Fred/George, or InuYasha/Sesshoumaru pairings on there.
So it really is a plausible theory, as odd as it may sound to most! I don't mean to gross anyone out of course. Sorry for any offense taken!

ConfusedBlonde · Post Posted: Dec 05, 2011 6:35 pm

Kurai27 wrote:
Farmy wrote:Ash and Cheryl? Totally doing it.
Ok, so I know this is a little off topic from what's being said now, but this theory kinda got blew off. But, it's actually kinda plausible considering that the Japanese like some of the stranger fetishes/complexes. This one included. I mean, has anyone ever read or watched Angel Sanctuary by Kaori Yuki? Don't get me wrong, she's awesome and her manga Godchild is amazing too, it even has some instances of sibling love in it. And I bet most of us on here have heard of Ouran Host Club, granted the Hitachiin twins aren't really together but they make themselves out to be for the girls. And not only is it popular in Japan but it is here as well, I mean has anyone been on FF.N lately? Practically any popular series with a set of siblings has at least one story with them paired together, I can't count how many times I have seen Fred/George, or InuYasha/Sesshoumaru pairings on there.
So it really is a plausible theory, as odd as it may sound to most! I don't mean to gross anyone out of course. Sorry for any offense taken!

But dude that's fandoms, not the Japanese in general. At least not as a whole. Some of the anime play on it like Ouran, but that's basically a spoof on fangirls anyway. HM games don't seem to follow that same pattern at all. I am absolutely positive that Marvelous did not intend for Cheryl and Ash's relationship to be anything but platonic sibling love.

Kurai27 · Post Posted: Dec 05, 2011 6:41 pm

ConfusedBlonde wrote:
Kurai27 wrote:
Farmy wrote:Ash and Cheryl? Totally doing it.
Ok, so I know this is a little off topic from what's being said now, but this theory kinda got blew off. But, it's actually kinda plausible considering that the Japanese like some of the stranger fetishes/complexes. This one included. I mean, has anyone ever read or watched Angel Sanctuary by Kaori Yuki? Don't get me wrong, she's awesome and her manga Godchild is amazing too, it even has some instances of sibling love in it. And I bet most of us on here have heard of Ouran Host Club, granted the Hitachiin twins aren't really together but they make themselves out to be for the girls. And not only is it popular in Japan but it is here as well, I mean has anyone been on FF.N lately? Practically any popular series with a set of siblings has at least one story with them paired together, I can't count how many times I have seen Fred/George, or InuYasha/Sesshoumaru pairings on there.
So it really is a plausible theory, as odd as it may sound to most! I don't mean to gross anyone out of course. Sorry for any offense taken!
But dude that's fandoms, not the Japanese in general. At least not as a whole. Some of the anime play on it like Ouran, but that's basically a spoof on fangirls anyway. HM games don't seem to follow that same pattern at all. I am absolutely positive that Marvelous did not intend for Cheryl and Ash's relationship to be anything but platonic sibling love.

I understand that, this is crazy theories anyway right? But it's not just fandoms when real writers write about the topic, even if they don't agree. It's a taboo thing, and that's what gets the readers attention... Anyway, I know Marvelous would never intend to have such a thing in their games. I was only responding to the comment that got blown off. I really didn't mean to cause a disturbance.... I'm really sorry!