The ToTT Theory Topic.

[family guy]

And to all you boys after the oracle she is cheating on you!!! cuz she's goin to those strip clubs gettin down with other guys! XD

[Lunadora]

For « Harvest Goddess »'s sake, don't double post.
And by the way... I go away for 3 days and, when I'm back, I only find theories about dead people and drug dealers? OMG people! You're getting too heavy on your theories!

[quigley]

o_o . . Quigley that's amazing! Ahaha it makes sense in a awesome deranged way XD


Ahahah I don't know if you saw the other page but we've determined that Nori and Ayame have drug battles since they both push drugs in the same towns. Nori just has too much time and grows her own, and we constantly re-stock Ayame with her "poision apples", "mushrooms" and "weeds" ;D

Haha, thanks! (And thanks to you, too, ConfusedBlonde.)

Lol, I did see that! That's hilarious, but totally believable. I love it.

I go away for 3 days and, when I'm back, I only find theories about dead people and drug dealers? OMG people! You're getting too heavy on your theories!

In my defense, I was also gone for 3 days, and during that time, I came up with my theory which involved death, but.........wait, what kind of defense is that? >_<

Here's a less creepy theory. I can't remember if I (or someone else) posted this already...stupid memory. >_< Sorry if I already did post it! And even sorrier if someone else did!

This might be my favorite of all of my theories, I think. (Sorry it's a bit long.)

Spoiler:

Ash is Cheryl's father.

Years ago, Julia, from Island of Happiness, visited Bluebell and was enamored with its animal farm.

But she was also enamored with the young, handsome farmhand.

...That's Ash, by the way.

The two young teens (at the time) fell madly and love and...well, you know where this is going.

Unfortunately, the news that Julia was pregnant was not celebrated joyously. Young, unmarried parents were looked down upon in that culture.

To keep it a secret and save Julia and Ash from being black marked for life, Jessica recommended that they pretend the baby was her own. Julia and Ash sadly agreed to the plan.

The baby was born and named Cheryl, after Julia's grandmother (it's plausible, right?).

Soon some of the other villagers grew suspicious of Julia, and began to shun her. As it got worse, Ash and Jessica also began to suffer from the villagers' suspicion. Along with a fear that the villagers could also direct their distrust towards Cheryl, Julia's heart was torn over having to pretend that the child was not her own. With all of this weighing on her, Julia finally decided to leave Bluebell and return home.

Ash begged her not to go, but Julia tearfully told him that it had to be done. She couldn't have just taken Cheryl with her, even if they hadn't pretended that she was Jessica's daughter, because then the villagers would still have shunned Ash, the father, and possibly Jessica as well. Not wanting to destroy any of their lives, Julia quietly left the village, and soon the suspicion regarding the family died down.

But before she left, she asked Ash to promise to always look out for Cheryl, and to let himself love another. Ash sadly agreed, and after one last passionate kiss, Julia left the town forever.

Ash knew that he must be strong, for all of them, so he did not let himself despair for too long. Instead, he directed his energy towards helping to raise Cheryl. Being a father, he felt a new sense of responsibility, and became devoted to helping those in need, particularly women and children.

Cheryl grew up thinking Ash was her brother, but felt a strange, inexplicable, obsession-like attachment to him. At times, she would tell Ash that he was the closest thing she had to a father, and would then be puzzled as to why Ash would choke up and quickly excuse himself.

She inherited both of her parent's love for animals, and her (real) mother's desire to help her (not real) mother with her shop. Unfortunately, she also inherited her real mother's cooking skill. Though the villagers were always perplexed as to why Cheryl could not cook even though Ash and Jessica were both fine chefs, they shrugged it off and never suspected anything odd.


(It's not that far from reality...I know it was a common practice long ago, when a young girl got pregnant, to pretend that it was her sibling instead.)

[Lunadora]

OMG! That all makes so much sense! But I like to think that you just don't let children cook, and that's why they always mess up the dishes. Not to mention that you would need a reason for Julia to be at Jessica's farm. Cover those and you get my trust on it!

[pshycho]

@Luna - You'll notice how I haven't posted on here in a while...
@Quig - OH MY GOSH IT ALL MAKES SENSE NOW!! You, my dear friend, are a genius.

[Lunadora]

Actually I already noticed. I've been reading 38 pages of a certain fan club and got updated on everything that happened while I was away. Things must be hard on you...

It is ok now.

[Integral Dragon]

What if sickly Ying grew up to be sickly Dia from Magical Melody...?

A quick link to Dia: http://www.fogu.com/hm/magical_melody/wives.php

(Then she best back off, cause Kurt is mine!)

[hmaddicted]

Ash and Cheryl? Totally doing it.

Ok, so I know this is a little off topic from what's being said now, but this theory kinda got blown off. But, it's actually kinda plausible considering that the Japanese like some of the stranger fetishes/complexes. This one included. I mean, has anyone ever read or watched Angel Sanctuary by Kaori Yuki? Don't get me wrong, she's awesome and her manga Godchild is amazing too, it even has some instances of sibling love in it. And I bet most of us on here have heard of Ouran Host Club, granted the Hitachiin twins aren't really together but they make themselves out to be for the girls. And not only is it popular in Japan but it is here as well, granted it isn't always real siblings but step or half or adoption or something similar. I mean has anyone been on FF.N lately? Practically any popular series with a set of siblings has at least one story with them paired together, I can't count how many times I have seen Fred/George, or InuYasha/Sesshoumaru pairings on there.
So it really is a plausible theory, as odd as it may sound to most! I don't mean to gross anyone out of course. Sorry for any offense taken!

Lol. I've been thinking the same thing about Ash and Cheryl since I started to play the game. And yes it's a taboo and yet popular theme in Japanese manga and anime (mostly in hentai and some in shoujo). Of course it's not outright in the game, but it seems like it could be hinted at as we suspect a relationship between Ayame and Hiro, Ash and Cam, Hiro and Kana, etc is hinted at.

[family guy]

Wow. I was waiting to figure out her name by myself.

I was too.

wait what happend i did spoil it what happend? i soi most things i put on here :/

[Lunadora]

You did not spoil it. If you did it would not have shown. Learn how to do things right for once!
And if you're not sure if it will be showing on spoiler or not you can ALWAYS use the PREVIEW to check if your post will be alright or not. But, of course, you don't mind it at all and will keep doing those stupid things. And the worst, you can't even edit your post, because you're a FISHIE! A DAMN STUPID FISHIE!

Come on, blame me as much as you want. I'm sure there are a whole lot of people that agree with me, they just are too scared to say anything. But you're getting on my nerves for some time already, so I won't hold back anymore.

And for those who wanted to figure her name out... don't worry, she wrote it wrong. You will still have the chance to get it. But be warned, the only way to get her real name is marrying her, which will take some time.

[quigley]

OMG! That all makes so much sense! But I like to think that you just don't let children cook, and that's why they always mess up the dishes. Not to mention that you would need a reason for Julia to be at Jessica's farm. Cover those and you get my trust on it!

Yeah, you could say it's just because she's young and inexperienced. It's just that I had already chosen to use Julia, before I even knew she was a bad cook. When I DID find out, I thought it would make a nice little addition.

As for a reason for Julia to be at Jessica's farm...does there really need to be one? Plenty of HM characters end up in places without much of a reason...even the ones from previous games who appear in other ones.

But if I had to make up a reason, I guess I'd just say that she heard that Bluebell was renowned for its livestock, and wanted to check it out. That's perfectly believable for the HM world.

[Lunadora]

[You just won me over, quig!

Spoiler:

Cheryl, from now on, is Ash's and Julia's daughter.

And I won't feel bad for this. I almost feel like writting a fanfic about this xD

[CyanideConfections]

quig, you are a genius.
and seeing as how we've made most of the characters work at the club in some way, i say that the other characters have their own club

Spoiler:

now this club is nothing like the strip club that the other characters have. this would be like one of those fancy country clubs for the finest of Bluebell and Konohana.
At this club, Mikhail plays soft classical music while wealthy, influential, and older (except for Hiro) individuals (such as the town mayors, the triplets, Howard, Yun) congregate to talk about politics while sipping on fine wine. the more eventful activities include betting on horse races and even some poker tournaments (but all are enjoyed quietly in a sophisticated manner)

light enough?

[Lunadora]

Light enough. And I would add to your theory that

Spoiler:

The horses used on the horse races belong to Kana. And all the other guys work as butlers.

Sorry, it's been my dream ever since I started reading Kaichou wa Maid-sama.

[CyanideConfections]

Light enough. And I would add to your theory that

Spoiler:

The horses used on the horse races belong to Kana. And all the other guys work as butlers.

Sorry, it's been my dream ever since I started reading Kaichou wa Maid-sama.

lol, yes! i wanted to add Kana to the country club, but what with his love for beer (and he gives off the 'party dude' vibe) i think that he'd be best suited for the... other club