Is This What's Going to Happen Now?

Ronin19 · Post Posted: Jul 24, 2012 12:48 pm

DuchessPinkcat 8686 wrote:Well, personally I would love to see Alice, Charles, and Renton come back. (Alice being a bachellorette and Charles being a bachelor.) And I think the reason they've brought the W.P back so many times is because there are an awful lot of ways to portray her. In DS and DS Cute, she was the bad girl. In IoH, she was portrayed as a little younger-ish, with teddy bears as company.In SI, she had a niece. In AP, her character design was changed, along with an added rivalry with the Wizard. So, this time, I hope they come up with a new idea! But, yeah, a lot of cameos failed. I still love Dirk, but in TToTT, they kinda watered down his personality(much like Karen and Gray.) I do like them though.

The thing is though, the Witch Princess in AP and in DS/DSC/IoH/SI/ToTT are two complete different people, which is why they both look different. I like to think there's a "Handheld World" and a "Console World". Characters from the Handheld World don't make cameos in the Console World and vice versa.

Lord_Banks · Post Posted: Jul 24, 2012 1:07 pm

dino-rawr75 wrote:Gray, but not the "I'm on Prozac" Gray from DS/C. The one from Mineral Town.

And more villagers, I want this to be a town, not just full of bachelors/rettes with questionable origin.

Yes! I've always felt that there really aren't ever enough people in HM games for there to be a town, a village yes, but not a town... Though if there were more people then it would be too hard to befriend them all...

Diva · Post Posted: Jul 24, 2012 7:37 pm

I personally would love to see Skye again ;v; I like the idea of seeing bachalors coming back in the new games and still being able to marry them.

Spoiler:

Genie9 · Post Posted: Jul 24, 2012 8:58 pm

I feel like their would be more of an uproar if the WP was added and she wasn't eligible though.

/blah I sound like a crazy fanboy.

They could pull an MM and release a game where they could combine two different villages into one, and put past candidates up for marriage. Like the IoH/SI cast with the ToT cast in a new village. But then again I'd rather see a new game with new villagers, and only a few cameos.

Ronin19 · Post Posted: Jul 24, 2012 9:49 pm

Diva wrote:I personally would love to see Skye again ;v; I like the idea of seeing bachalors coming back in the new games and still being able to marry them.

I wouldn't mind if he showed up again. He's a fun character.

Genie9 wrote:I feel like their would be more of an uproar if the WP was added and she wasn't eligible though.

I don't really think so. She's been in 5 games and in all of them you can marry her. I would like someone else to marry. With her new appearance and being a marriage candidate again, I just feel like she took away a bachelorette slot from someone who really deserved it. I don't feel this way about Amir, Dirk, or Alisa simply because Amir and Dirk have only appeared twice and Alisa's only available to be married in one game.

Lord_Banks · Post Posted: Jul 25, 2012 4:27 am

I'd kinda like to marry Witchkins

She was really cute in SI, and I thought it was kinda cool and nice of the WP to take on an apprentice! Unfortunately for me, it probably won't happen

pshycho · Post Posted: Jul 25, 2012 6:54 am

I think it would be cool to see a grown up version of Witchkins and possibly make her a bachelorette. She'd be very similar to WP, but I think it would be a cool twist on things at least.

Lin · Post Posted: Jul 25, 2012 8:07 am

I wish Chase would come back, but maybe on a handheld game. xD

Ronin19 · Post Posted: Jul 25, 2012 8:14 am

Lord_Banks wrote:I'd kinda like to marry Witchkins She was really cute in SI, and I thought it was kinda cool and nice of the WP to take on an apprentice! Unfortunately for me, it probably won't happen

pshycho wrote:I think it would be cool to see a grown up version of Witchkins and possibly make her a bachelorette. She'd be very similar to WP, but I think it would be a cool twist on things at least.

If she's like the Witch Princess, Witchkins may be immortal as well and may not age at all. Although, it may be funny if she does become a bachelorette, maybe I wouldn't mind having Witch Princess as a bachelorette again for the sole purpose of having a random event where you raise both of the ladies's hearts to red and they force you to choose. When you choose, the other's heart goes back to black. The random event can happen many times.

Lin wrote:I wish Chase would come back, but maybe on a handheld game. xD

I wouldn't mind that either, but first I think the cast of ToT/AP should all be ported to the Handheld World. Otherwise, not gonna happen.

ButxAxDream · Post Posted: Jul 25, 2012 9:17 am

Rock should come back but have a personality that is more like his AnWL and less like his Cute personality. (I enjoyed both, however)

SailorDanielle · Post Posted: Jul 25, 2012 9:36 am

@Ronin - I agree with you about converting them into the Handheld world. All of the people in the console world (with the exception of Wizard, Vivi, and HK) have only appeared twice, which is basically on the two console games. I think it would be pretty great to have the ToT/AP folks on handheld.

Here's a List of HM bachelors that are only Marriagable candidates in TWO GAMES OR LOWER:
Every bachelor in ToT/AP, every bachelor in ANWL, Skye (DS/C), Won (M/FoMT), Kappa (M/FoMT every bachelor in Grand Bazaar, every bachelor in MM, every bachelor in ToTT, and every bachelor in IoH/SI including Will.

Now here's the list of HM bachelorettes that are only marriageable candidates in two games or lower:
Every bachelorette in ToT/AP, Keira (DS/C), every bachelorette in AWL, Leia (DS/C), Alisa (ToTT/SI/IoH) every bachelorette in Grand Bazaar, every bachelorette in MM, every bachelorette in STH, every bachelorette in ToTT, and every bachelorette in IoH/SI including Lily.

Feel free to correct me if any of this is incorrect or I need to add any more ^_^

Lord_Banks · Post Posted: Jul 25, 2012 11:25 am

SailorDanielle wrote:@Ronin - I agree with you about converting them into the Handheld world. All of the people in the console world (with the exception of Wizard, Vivi, and HK) have only appeared twice, which is basically on the two console games. I think it would be pretty great to have the ToT/AP folks on handheld.

Here's a List of HM bachelors that are only Marriagable candidates in TWO GAMES OR LOWER:
Every bachelor in ToT/AP, Skye (DS/C), Won (M/FoMT), Kappa (M/FoMT every bachelor in Grand Bazaar, every bachelor in MM, every bachelor in ToTT, and every bachelor in IoH/SI including Will.

Now here's the list of HM bachelorettes that are only marriageable candidates in two games or lower:
Every bachelorette in ToT/AP, Keira (DS/C), Leia (DS/C), Alisa (ToTT/SI/IoH) every bachelorette in Grand Bazaar, every bachelorette in MM, every bachelorette in STH, every bachelorette in ToTT, and every bachelorette in IoH/SI including Lily.

Feel free to correct me if any of this is incorrect or I need to add any more ^_^

You forgot all the bachelors and bachelorettes if Forget-Me-Not Valley... How ironic!

SailorDanielle · Post Posted: Jul 25, 2012 11:40 am

I added them now, thank you. I thought they were in 3 games for a second xD

Lord_Banks · Post Posted: Jul 25, 2012 1:16 pm

SailorDanielle wrote:I added them now, thank you. I thought they were in 3 games for a second xD

Technically they are if you count HMDS and HMDSCute as different games, though they really aren't... Not enough to make a difference anyway... And ANWL and AWL are kinda the same, just added Lumina as a bachelorette and minor differences.

Post Posted: Jul 25, 2012 2:46 pm

Ronin19 wrote:
Genie9 wrote:I feel like their would be more of an uproar if the WP was added and she wasn't eligible though.
I don't really think so. She's been in 5 games and in all of them you can marry her. I would like someone else to marry. With her new appearance and being a marriage candidate again, I just feel like she took away a bachelorette slot from someone who really deserved it. I don't feel this way about Amir, Dirk, or Alisa simply because Amir and Dirk have only appeared twice and Alisa's only available to be married in one game.

I agree. It makes me glad that there's no real male equivalent of her, because if they kept using the same bachelor over and over I'd get sick of him too.