Sharron vs Melody

[cowharmony]

Melody, because she's a sing-songy happy little witchy ^_^

[Minorou]

I'd say it's even. Melody has such a great, charming personality. How could you not be friendly in return? On the other hand, Sharron's mysteriousness just has a certain charm to it... and has a sort of exotic beauty. I can't really decide either way.

[hentaipeter]

Melody, because she's sweeter. Sharron creeps me out, and she loves you because you give her fire crystals.
Melody likes you because you get nekkid.

[Astral Angel]

i kinda don't like both of them..but i'd pick sharron cause melody's little witch outfit seems kinda childish to me...

[Lunchbox]

Melody. Sharron reminds me of, of.... an old person. O_o

I agree. Pick Melody! She is a total sweetheart.
Sharron looks like a sickly, old lady. Ha.

[No offense to Sharron lovers. She has a great personality.]

[weltall]

I like Sharron because she has a mystical aura around her and she kinda reminds me Keria which I loved a lot. Also I would like her anyway cause I guess this kind of magical girls are my type =. Also I do not like melody, first because I do not understand why she is dressed like a witch when she runs a bathhouse and second because she seems scary, wanting to build a bathouse inside a cave full of lava and being sad because that big poisonous plant boss died and her bathhouse idea is ruined. Geez >>

[sircusa]

Melody does say why she dresses up as a witch and why she runs a bath house though they're not very good reasons @_@ I like Melody though because I'm a mage =P Also, she's always friendly and Sharron creeps me out -.-

[Princess Reina]

Melody > Sharron.

The second one is scary; her voice, her eyes and she is too tall. She sounds like 300 years old woman

[weltall]

Melody does say why she dresses up as a witch and why she runs a bath house though they're not very good reasons @_@ I like Melody though because I'm a mage =P Also, she's always friendly and Sharron creeps me out -.-

Well I would comment you but you said that the reasons she gives are really not that good. I actually liked her before getting the game but I thought should would be a cute witch.

Melody > Sharron.

The second one is scary; her voice, her eyes and she is too tall. She sounds like 300 years old woman

=3 Exactly like a magical girl. Which is why she reminds me Keria and which is why I like her so much =3

[Bahbee_boi]

melody. sharron is nigh-unapproachable. i like girls who you can actually talk to.

10 FP, 10 LP.

She is very nice to me after I unlocked the Kasmir Ruins.

Tori is the one your thinking of.

Melody > Sharron.

The second one is scary; her voice, her eyes and she is too tall. She sounds like 300 years old woman

Both Keria, Goddess and the Witch from HMDS, are all probably over 1000 years old.

[Rinix]

i like melody better because sharron creeps me out.

[Tapestries]

I like Sharron better, simply because of her character design. I wasn't a huge fan of Witch Princess, either. Melody's still cute though.

[Azumi-chan]

Sharon!
She's beautiful and mysterious.

Melody is annoying..
I don't like her design either ~.

[Meshikins]

I like them both majorly, but I prefer Melody over Sharron. She's just so much cuter~ Plus I like people interested in baths. In the Suikoden games, my favorite characters are the bath guys. 8D

[hentaipeter]

Sharron just told me she doesn't sleep in the Inn. I am creeped out. Does she sleep in the graveyard?